A cross-cultural perspective on academic resilience, academic vulnerability, and student attitudes towards mathematics: An analysis of TIMSS 2019 data

Authors: Vasiliki Pitsia and Rachel Perkins

DOI: https://doi.org/10.70092/IJE.49.04

 

Abstract

The study of academic resilience has received much attention in international large-scale studies of achievement in recent times and can provide insights into why some children coming from lower socioeconomic backgrounds do well academically, while others from similar backgrounds do not do as well. Applying definitions of academic resilience that meaningfully operationalise its two core constructs, adversity and successful outcomes, can be challenging. These difficulties become even more pronounced when attempting to apply such definitions across different countries. Considering that and the policy focus on science, technology, engineering, and mathematics (STEM) across many countries, this study uses Trends in International Mathematics and Science Study (TIMSS) data to examine academic resilience in the context of mathematics. Academic resilience is defined as betterthan- expected achievement outcomes among students from lower socioeconomic backgrounds. The study focuses on four countries that are readily comparable on measures of adversity and successful outcomes: Australia, England, Ireland, and the United States. Academically resilient students are compared to academically vulnerable students, identified as those with similar levels of socioeconomic status but lower achievement. The aim of the study is to examine whether academic resilience in mathematics can be predicted by the extent to which students feel confident in, like learning, and value mathematics, and to examine the extent to which this may vary across countries. Based on the results of the binary logistic regression models, which accounted for student gender, how confident students felt in mathematics statistically significantly predicted academic resilience as opposed to academic vulnerability across all countries. Gender (favouring females) was only statistically significantly associated with academic resilience in Australia. Methodological implications and implications for educational policy are discussed.